
Keto Not Working Anymore After 40? What Nobody Tells Women About Keto and Hormones
By Maria Merlo, Certified Functional Medicine Health Coach · Splendhealth, Greenville, SC
Your friend lost 15 pounds on keto. Your coworker swears she's never had more energy. So you tried it too, and two weeks later you're exhausted, cold, not sleeping, your hair is shedding and the scale barely moved.
You didn't fail keto. You may have a body in midlife that's asking for something different.
Keto isn't good or bad. It's a tool. For some women it helps a lot. For others, especially in perimenopause, it can push hormones that are already struggling in the wrong direction. Here's what nobody tells you before you start.
What keto actually does
On a ketogenic diet, you eat very few carbohydrates (usually under 20 to 50 grams a day), moderate protein and a lot of fat. When carbs are that low, your liver starts turning fat into ketones, and your body and brain use them for fuel instead of sugar. That state is called nutritional ketosis.
Keto wasn't invented for weight loss. It was first used in the 1920s to help children with epilepsy, and it's still used medically for that today.
The quick weight loss in the first weeks is real, but a good part of it is water: when insulin drops, your kidneys let go of sodium and water.
Where keto can help
Insulin resistance. If your blood sugar and insulin are high, cutting carbs can lower them quickly. That's why keto often helps with blood sugar and triglycerides.
PCOS. Many women with PCOS are insulin resistant. Pooled studies of women with PCOS who followed keto for 45 days or more found lower free testosterone, a better LH/FSH ratio and higher SHBG. Most of these studies were short and in women with extra weight.
Why keto may not work for you anymore
This is what I hear most often: "Keto worked for me in my 30s. Now I do exactly the same thing and nothing happens, or I feel awful."
It's not your willpower. Your body changed, and the rules changed with it. Every hormone affects the others (that's the Hormone Dance), and very-low-carb eating touches several of them at once. Here's what's going on.
1. Your hormones changed the rules
Estrogen helps your muscles and liver respond to insulin. As it swings and then falls in perimenopause, your body handles carbs and insulin less smoothly, and fat starts to move toward your belly.
The large SWAN study followed women through menopause with body scans. At the start of the transition, the rate of fat gain doubled and lean mass (muscle) started to go down, while total weight didn't change much. In other words, the scale can stay the same while your body composition gets worse.
Keto is very good at moving the scale in the first weeks, mostly with water. It doesn't fix the shift from muscle to fat. That's why so many women "lose weight" on keto and still don't like what they see or how they feel.
2. Keto can cost you muscle, and muscle is your metabolism
After 40, your muscles respond less to protein (this is called anabolic resistance), so you need more protein, not less, to keep them. On keto, when carbs are very low and protein isn't enough, your body makes its own sugar from protein, and some of that comes from muscle.
In a carefully controlled metabolic-ward study, people ate the same calories first on a higher-carb diet and then on keto. On keto, body fat loss actually slowed, and they used more protein and lost more lean mass. (That study was in men, but the mechanism is the same for us, and we have less muscle to spare.)
This matters because muscle is where most of the sugar from a meal goes. Lose muscle and insulin resistance gets worse, which is the very thing you went keto to fix.
3. Eating less tells your body it's not safe: thyroid and cortisol
Keto is very filling, so many women end up undereating without realizing it. Add intermittent fasting, a hard workout and a stressful week, and your body reads it as scarcity. Its answer is to protect you: cortisol goes up, active thyroid hormone (T3) goes down, and more of it is turned into reverse T3, the "brake" version. Your metabolism slows down to save energy, and your body holds on to fat.
Keto itself can push in the same direction:
Thyroid. In a small, well-controlled study, healthy adults (mostly women) ate the same calories on keto or on a higher-carb diet for 3 weeks each. On keto, their T3 went down, even though TSH stayed normal. TSH is often the only thyroid test people get, so if you're tired, cold and losing hair on keto, a basic test may not show why. (If this sounds like you, read Tired, Cold and Losing Hair, but Your Thyroid Test Is "Normal"?.)
Cortisol. In a Harvard feeding study, a very-low-carb diet helped people burn more calories, but it also raised cortisol and a marker of inflammation (CRP). A moderate, low-glycemic diet had similar metabolic benefits without that stress signal.
4. Cortisol can keep your blood sugar high, even with no carbs
Cortisol tells your liver to release sugar so you have fuel for a "threat." So if you're sleeping badly, waking up with night sweats or running on stress, your fasting blood sugar can stay high even when you're barely eating carbs. Many women see this on their glucose monitor and can't understand it.
I call it stacked stressors: keto + fasting 16 hours + intense workouts + coffee on an empty stomach + poor sleep. Each one alone might be fine. Stacked together in perimenopause, your body reads it as danger. And for some women, that cortisol and blood sugar roller coaster makes hot flashes and 3 a.m. wake-ups worse. (More on that in Hot Flash Relief Without Hormones.)
5. Keto has no fat-burning magic
Yes, on keto you burn more fat for fuel. But you also eat a lot more fat. In the same metabolic-ward study, when calories were equal, keto did not lead to more body fat loss than a higher-carb diet. Keto works mainly because it helps people eat less.
So when the "keto" foods creep in (fat bombs, bulletproof coffee, cheese, nuts by the handful, keto desserts) or a few glasses of wine come back, it quietly stops working. And if you've dieted on and off for years, your body has learned to run on less, so the same plan gives you less each time.
6. Your gut and estrogen clearance need fiber
Your gut helps clear used estrogen out of your body. A group of gut bacteria (sometimes called the estrobolome) decides how much of it leaves and how much gets sent back into circulation. Those bacteria run on fiber and plants.
Keto done as "bacon, cheese and butter" is low in fiber, and that can mean constipation, a less diverse gut and more estrogen recirculating at a time when your hormones are already swinging. If you do keto, it has to be a plant-heavy keto.
7. Your bones and your workouts need some carbs
In a study of elite race walkers, just 3.5 weeks of keto (same calories) raised a marker of bone breakdown and lowered markers of bone building. Those were young athletes, but after menopause, protecting your bones becomes a priority, so this is worth knowing.
Exercise physiologist Dr. Stacy Sims makes a simple point: women in midlife shouldn't be afraid of carbohydrate. Choose the type and time it. Your body needs some carbs around strength and interval workouts to recover and build muscle, and muscle is one of your best tools for blood sugar after 40.
8. It might not be about food at all
Thyroid problems, including Hashimoto's, become more common in women in midlife, and the symptoms (fatigue, weight gain, feeling cold, hair loss, low mood) look a lot like perimenopause. Iron, vitamin D and sleep can also be in the way. If you're doing "everything right" and nothing moves, it's time to test, not to restrict more.
Signs keto isn't working for your body
You're sleeping worse or waking up between 2 and 4 a.m.
You feel colder, more tired, or your hair is shedding.
You're more anxious, irritable or low.
You're constipated.
Your cycles changed, or hot flashes got worse.
Your workouts feel harder and you're not getting stronger.
Your fasting blood sugar is creeping up.
The scale won't move, or your waist is growing.
If you checked a few of these, your body is giving you information. Listen to it.
Who should not start keto on their own
Talk with your doctor first if you:
Take diabetes medication, especially insulin, sulfonylureas or SGLT2 inhibitors. Your doses may need to change, and the risk of very low blood sugar or ketoacidosis is real.
Have liver, pancreas, gallbladder or kidney problems, or a rare disorder of fat metabolism.
Are pregnant or breastfeeding.
Have a history of disordered eating. A very strict diet isn't the right path.
If you still want to try keto
Keto can be a useful short-term tool for some women. If you try it, do it the Splendhealth way:
Test first. Fasting glucose, fasting insulin, A1c, a full thyroid panel (not just TSH) and a lipid panel. Then you know your starting point and can see what's really changing. Some women see LDL cholesterol rise a lot on keto, so it's worth rechecking.
Eat real food, mostly plants. Non-starchy vegetables at every meal, quality protein (fish, eggs, poultry), olive oil, avocado, nuts and seeds. Keep processed meats and cheese as extras, not the base.
Prioritize protein. About a palm-sized portion at every meal helps protect your muscle.
Get ahead of keto flu. The first week can bring fatigue, headache, dizziness and constipation. Drink enough water and add electrolytes (salt, potassium, magnesium).
Watch your body, not just the scale. If your sleep, mood, energy, cycles or hair get worse, that's information. Stop and reassess.
Plan your exit. The biggest mistake is jumping straight back to old habits. Bring carbs back slowly (beans, root vegetables, fruit, whole grains) and see how your blood sugar and energy respond. That's how you avoid the rebound.
What usually works better after 40
For most of the women I work with, the answer isn't "no carbs." It's smart carbs: enough protein, lots of fiber and plants, slow carbs like beans, berries, sweet potato and whole grains, and carbs placed around your workouts. This steadies blood sugar and insulin without pushing your thyroid and cortisol in the wrong direction.
And it's personal. A continuous glucose monitor and the right labs can show how your body handles carbs, so you don't have to guess.
How Splendhealth can help
I'm Maria Merlo, a certified Functional Medicine Health Coach in Greenville, SC. Before choosing any diet, keto or not, we look at how your blood sugar, thyroid, stress hormones, gut and sex hormones are working together. Then we build an eating plan that fits your labs, your symptoms and your life, so you lose what you want to lose without losing your energy.
Every program includes a complete lab panel, and I work alongside your doctor, never instead of them. Learn more about the Feel Splendid Again program.
Book your free 30-minute Wellness Clarity Call →
About the author: Maria Merlo is a Certified Functional Medicine Health Coach (AFMC, School of Applied Functional Medicine) and an Institute for Integrative Nutrition graduate. Read her story.
This article is for education only and is not medical advice. It doesn't diagnose, treat or cure any condition. If you take medication or have a health condition, talk with your doctor before changing your diet.
Sources
Masood W et al. Ketogenic Diet. StatPearls, NCBI Bookshelf.
Iacovides S et al. Could the ketogenic diet induce a shift in thyroid function and support a metabolic advantage in healthy participants? A pilot randomized-controlled-crossover trial. PLoS ONE 2022.
Ebbeling CB et al. Effects of dietary composition on energy expenditure during weight-loss maintenance. JAMA 2012;307:2627–2634.
Khalid K et al. Effects of ketogenic diet on reproductive hormones in women with polycystic ovary syndrome: a meta-analysis. J Endocr Soc 2023 (summary).
The effects of ketogenic diet and very-low-energy ketogenic therapy on PCOS: systematic review and meta-analysis. Reprod Biol Endocrinol 2025.
Paoli A et al. Beyond weight loss: a review of the therapeutic uses of very-low-carbohydrate (ketogenic) diets. Eur J Clin Nutr 2013.
Greendale GA et al. Changes in body composition and weight during the menopause transition. JCI Insight 2019 (SWAN).
Hall KD et al. Energy expenditure and body composition changes after an isocaloric ketogenic diet in overweight and obese men. Am J Clin Nutr 2016.
Heikura IA et al. A short-term ketogenic diet impairs markers of bone health in response to exercise. Front Endocrinol 2020.
